556.
Decline of civilisations
Generally,
the decline of civilisations is faster than their laborious rise. This is
called the ‘Seneca effect’, after the Roman philosopher, who said something in
that vein. (Bardi, 2020).But every decline is unique, gradual or short and
calamitous. The decline of the Roman empire lasted two hundred of the thousand
years of the empire, but it was gradual. There were several causes. One was the
loss of martial spirit and the sense of civic responsibility that was strong in
the Roman republic, since people were later more inclined to savour the fruits
of prosperity. This created a problem in defending the long border of the
empire. At first, the Romans tried to compensate the paucity of troops by
concentrating them in fortifications, ready to rush to where fighting was
needed. This was not adequate due to the slowness of communication and travel,
and there were invasions of Germanic tribes.
The
account in this piece borrows heavily from Cantor (1993).
Among
the invaders, the Visigoths were on the run for the Huns that threatened to
overrun their original territory. They had no hostile intent, and first simply
sought refuge in the Roman empire, but when that was not readily granted, they
resorted to violence. Later, they fled to Spain, where they instituted a not
very effective kingship. Not very effective, because they could not halt the Islamic
invasion from the south. After the Visigoths came the Ostrogoths, who had been
occupied by the Huns. They, invaded the Roman empire, where they sought to
install their own kingship.
The
Roman empire had a Western and an Eastern part, the former centred in Rome and
the latter in Constantinople. The Eastern empire held on longer, defended by
the fortress Constantinople. Its emperor Justinian sought to restore the whole
Roman empire, but failed. Germanic tribes from the north were partly
conscripted in the Roman army, but this kindled their ambition for
independence.
The
Romans left a Gallo-Roman enclave in south-west France, and it took until
around 700 until that was fully integrated with the northern rule of the
Franks, with their Merovingian kingdom.
Roman
law was codified under Justinian, and came to be the legal framework for the
whole of continental Europe. It is different from original Germanic law in that
it codifies the will of the emperor, while the old German law was a ‘folk law,
‘determined by the people. which is still present in the ‘case law’. in the UK
and USA. That law is still in force in the Entire European continent. Some old Roman
roads in France are still in use.
In
contrast with the long decline of the Roman empire, the Frankish kingdom of the
Merovingians met with a sudden and calamitous collapse. It had a bad name for bringing
mentally backward and deficient family members to power. They considered their
kingdom as private property, and had no social or educational program for their
society. They were succeeded by the Carolingian kingdom, which, under
Charlemagne, who usurped power with papal aid, who did have a social and
educational programme, but that rise also collapsed after Charlemagne, in the
eighth century. The Frankish kingdoms were vulnerable to decline. Their system
was a king with a tiny elite, and if the king died, the country receded into a
primitive society of uneducated, illiterate peasantry. That applied also to the
Carolingians.
The
Russian Tsarist empire fell to the communist revolution, but held its coherence
under that radically different ideology of Communism. Later. under Putin, it rekindled
the old Tsarist authoritarian suppressive ideology of a holy mother Russia that
was now deemed superior to the degenerate western cultures.
Other
societies across the world were usurped by western colonial powers. I cannot
begin to describe the rise and decline of powers in China and Japan.
What
I wanted to show in this item of the blog, is that indeed there has been a widespread
pattern of the rise and decline of civilisations, but with a wide variety of the
patterns of speed, and depth of decline and loss.
Bardi,
U. 2020, Before the collapse: a guide to the other side of growth, Springer.
Cantor,
N.F. 1993, Civilisation of the Middle Ages, New York: Harper Collins.
No comments:
Post a Comment